Quote:
Originally Posted by Best day
Greenie, I don't appreciate your argumentative nature. This board is for discussion. Since you apparently know it all I don't know why you are here. Has it ever occurred to you that in a cooler climate the plant may grow different? That is the problem with thinking you know it all. You stop listening and stop learning.
Pitangadiego grows his Manzano in a very similar climate to mine and says he has the same experience. Bencelest grows Manzano in California and says they get to 12-14'. Interstingly I found an old post of yours where you say, "i prefer the manzano.The d. brazilian will will fruit anywhere from 8 to 10 ft while the manzano will hit about 12." I think you need to make up your mind.
Brazilian or Manzano?
Bill |
getsue, if you took my comments as argumentative, I apologize because thats not who I am. I was trying to help with the asking of pics and description as compared to what ive grown for a very long time.
Please don't judge in saying the I know it all because I don't.
Please don't question why I am on this forum like you just did.
I always listen and Im always learning.
[QUOTE
Quote:
=Greenie;334290]maybe.... you grew something else that wasn't a true manzano lol! Ive grown Brazilians both forms so I KNOW THE DIFFERENCE.
Quote:
=Greenie;334290]maybe.... you grew something else that wasn't a true manzano lol! Ive grown Brazilians both forms so I KNOW THE DIFFERENCE.
Anyways, thats the fun part of this hobby...if you don't like something about what you have then just start fresh.
|
Anyways, thats the fun part of this hobby...if you don't like something about what you have then just start fresh.
|
I made it clear in finishing the sentence that if someone doesnt like the growth habits of a certain variety due to their personal reason to get rid of them. I know because ive done it more thanI can count.So,I basically told you that I shared your same feeling.
Yes, cooler climates will induce bananas to grow taller and so will shade but when you say that your banana plants snap then is a big question and I was only trying to help you figure out what it might be. (mysore? (big bunches though)
When I said 9ft It was a quick shoot confused with another. I later posted a picture with a Manzano next to a 10 ft PVC to remind myself ..did you see it? So yes, I can attest to having 12ft plants and taller and also shorter flowerings at 9-10ft.
One more thing...when I put Lol it means to be funny not made fun off.I was trying to add some humor to the story while we live through these tough times of 2020.I think I have been a contributing member to this forum and I have always tried to help in whichever way I can.
Again,if I offended you or anyone in any way I apologize.
