Quote:
Originally Posted by venturabananas
I've only tried FHIA 1, 17, and 18 so far. Personally, I wouldn't bother with 17 because it is so similar to the Cavendish I can buy in the supermarket, and kind of nasty when overripe, but it is super productive. FHIA-01 and 18 are both very tasty and sturdy plants.
Thinking about the parentage of the varieties may help you decide. FHIA-01, 18, and SH-3640 all have Dwarf Brazilian as the female parent and so have some of the tartness of that variety. FHIA-02 and 17 are sweet varieties without any tartness, because their parents don't (Williams and Gros Michel -- Highgate -- as female parents respectively). Then there are some FHIA varieties that were derived largely from and intended to be cooking bananas (e.g., FHIA-03 and 25). I think some people like FHIA-03 as a dessert banana, and the plant is tough as nails from what I understand, but I can't comment on its flavor.
|
This is really helpful; thanks! After reading your post, I think I'm between the FHIA-02 and the SH-3640. I've read great things about the Sh-3640, but my only concern is if its too similar to the Goldfinger. Do you know if the SH-3640 and Goldfinger share any other genetic stock in common other than the Dwarf Brazilian? There was a FHIA publication I saw somewhere that said both the Goldfinger and the SH-3640 are AAAB hybrids, but gave no other info on SH-3640 genetics. The most interesting thing that intrigued me about the FHIA-17 like you said is that one of it's parents is Gros Michel, but I've been told it would be better to grow a dwarf Gros Michel instead of the FHIA-17 because the original variety's flavor is so much better. Does anyone have any experiences with FHIA-02? Thanks again for all of the help everyone!