Jamie p

Well, it's official! My Ice Cream is actually a Namwah, and my gros michel us beginning to look a lot like my Gran Nain if in fact that is what it is as well! I live in Florida hill's land of the mystery bananas. I will learn to pay more attention to posts on here next time. I am desperately seeking a Gros Michel and I will not give up on my quest.

JP

At least namwah is good... but I understand your frustration.

CTPalm

I don't know how they stay in business!

Jamie p

So far the only thing I'm sure of is they are banana plants. Lol I will say this. The plants I got from Wellspring are what they say they are if that helps anyone.

robguz24

Consider it a blessing in disguise. Namwah is a much better tasting and more productive banana.

__________________
My micro-farm

Stay on my Big Island banana farm cottage

hydroid

+1 what Rob said, Namwah is a notch above.

blownz281

They stay in business because people keep buying from them.

Kat2

So can I trust Wellspring?

__________________

Jamie p

Thanks guys. I don't know a lot about Namwah but from what you say maybe I'll take it as a blessing in disguise. As far as wellspring I have had good luck ,plants are small like fl hill but at least they are what they say they are.

Snarkie

I understand your consternation. You expected ice cream and got sherbet. In your case it may be a good thing, but how can you trust a company that doesn't even know what it is selling?!

If I buy a Honda Shadow, I don't want a Vespa shipped to me instead!

__________________
Doug (D.A. Hänks) http://www.imdb.com/name/nm2955582/?ref_=fn_al_nm_1


The Only Eastern Redwood Forest in America




"Nuke my 'nanners, will you?!"

hydroid

Most places are gonna have the Ice Cream mis-labeled as Namwah. It's how I got my first Namwah at a local Nursery, (no regrets) you can do a search on the forum here. Not defending the Nursery and I understand that you should be able to order with confidence. But from what I'm seeing, I don't think I would buy from those folks with the feedback I see here. But Ice Cream/Namwah is the exception to the rule and requires you to do your homework. There are several members here who can probably hook you up with the "Real Blue Java" if you check around.

pitangadiego

As far as I can tell, every "ice Cream" at Home Depot and several other places is really a Tall Namwah. Bought several from various places and had the same results. Finally found the real deal from the friend of a friend. Not a bad thing. They have a lot more fruit and much sweeter.

__________________
Encanto Farms Nursery
http://encantofarms.com
We Be Bananas
http://webebananas.com

Jamie p

I wonder if that mistake goes all the way back to agri starts or wherever they come from?

crazy banana

Maybe in case of the Ice Cream / Namwah mix-up but not if you get 4 Orinoco instead of your order Saba, Namwah, Ice Cream and Dwarf Cavendish. That is simply negligence....
Agri Starts should have corrected the Namwah/Ice Cream mistake years ago. Many people with the "real deal" including myself have offered them the real one, but they have also refused to take action.
IMO that is not acceptable. If I want to order a Namwah, I should be able to get it from a reputable nursery. If I order an Ice Cream, I should get just that. This mistake (not just by Florida Hill or Agri Starts) has been tolerated and even excused (like some of the previous posts) way too long, but if there is no plaintiff there is no defendant.

Going Bananas

Hello gang!
I thought I would try practicing
posting pics of my recent orders
last May 29, 2015 from FHN...


FHN Ice BJ Cream

Banana Gallery - FHN ice BJ cream
FHN Ice BJ Cream same as above


FHN Brazilian supposedly with red splotches/stains on the leaves.


FHN Manzano

I also ordered the Mona Lisa which I gave to my brother.
The ML was the first to open a new leaf
and seems to be the fastest grower
and quick to aclimatize.
The Ice Cream(I hope?) seems to be a close second.

What do you guys think?
Whats the verdict from the experts on here?
You guys get the same plants from those who ordered recently?

If I had to do it over...even if these were real or not,
I really would prefer to purchase the corm or the pup.
It would give you a head start on the growing cycle of the plant.

Cheers!

Going Bananas

Dog gonit!
I have to reread the instructions
on posting the pics.

BTW Happy PUPS Day
to all the fathers in this site!

Snarkie

Did they send you a Rembrandt instead?

__________________
Doug (D.A. Hänks) http://www.imdb.com/name/nm2955582/?ref_=fn_al_nm_1


The Only Eastern Redwood Forest in America




"Nuke my 'nanners, will you?!"

Lau

Your pictures are in the gallery so that's good. When you find the picture you want to put in the post you need to copy the first line under the photo and paste. It's a little harder with the copy and paste from iphone. I always look at the preview before I submitt to make sure everything gets copied. Only having my iPhone I'm not sure what it looks like. I hope that was helpful.

Susan

Kat2

I'm not an attorney nor have I ever purchased from FH and won't so I don't have a dog in this fight but, if it can be proven that they are repeatedly selling merchandise that is not as advertised, they are breaking a few laws I suspect. Sure, everyone makes occasional mistakes; a good merchant generally attempts, apologetically, to remedy these few errors. They do not repeatedly refuse to acknowledge such and insinuate that the customer is wrong.

What to do? You can report them to Garden Watchdog and state your issues on every garden forum or you, the injured customer, can pursue legal remedies. Gardeners are, as a group, very forgiving but there comes a time when one takes a stand if only to protect his fellow dirty fingered friends.

This might be a good place to put in a plug for Simmons Plant Farm. After wanting to order from them for over 20 years, I finally have my very own dirt so I purchased berry plants. 5 each (minimum) of several varieties. I'm fighting a new climate and unprepared planting areas (I'm growing in pots for now) so not every bare root "took"; I anticipated that figuring that as long as I got at least 1 of each at their prices I'd be happy. Sadly 2 groups of 5 did absolutely nothing. Fully aware that I was beyond the 10 day warranty, I sent an e-mail to let them know. I didn't expect a reply and certainly not an offer to replace next year or refund my money. I haven't decided what to do; I wanted the plants now and the lack of growth may partially be my fault. They're on my good vendor list for sure.

__________________

Jamie p

I'm wondering if Florida hill is affiliated with TY TY in Georgia . Kinda sounds like one of there many aliases . Just a thought I guess.