Unknown Seeded Banana Presented for ID

bigdog · 03-08-2007, 05:35 PM

These are Rob's pictures of a seeded banana growing in Balboa Park, San Diego, CA. I've eliminated a bunch of seeded species, but I sure can't place it! Any ideas? The flower pic is kind of out of focus, and for that Rob apologizes! J/K Rob!

Gabe15 · 03-08-2007, 08:51 PM

When I first saw these awhile back I thought maybe they were M. itinerans by the fruit, but that does not look right at all now. Then I thought maybe M. sikkimensis but that does not match either. The closet description Im thinking now is M. thomsonii. It would be nice to see a photo of the seeds if possible.

jeffreyp · 03-08-2007, 08:55 PM

It reminds me of Mysore, so maybe an indian variety is somewhere on the right track..

bigdog · 03-08-2007, 09:21 PM

Some more info from Rob (hey Rob...weigh in here!). The pseudostems are about 28" in diameter. Leaf + petiole length is about 10'. Pseudostem height about 20'. The fruit is about 6" long, and apple/pear flavored.

Hey Gabe, some characteristics of this plant do remind me of M. thomsonii, like the semi-pendulous infloresence, and the waxy bloom on the upper pseudostem. The fruits of this plant are much larger than M. thomsonii though, and the leaves look to be wider and rounded at the base, unlike M. thomsonii's narrower, lanceolate leaves.

You know, it does resemble what has been sold as M. itinerans here at Agri-Starts and Banana-tree.com (but looks like M. yunnanensis). The fruit bunch doesn't look quite right though.

I'm thinking it could be a hybrid. Gabe, can you direct Markku over here to have a look?

RobG7aChattTN · 03-09-2007, 04:13 PM

That pretty much covers it. The seeds looked exactly like my M. sikkimensis that I got mail order last year, but I'm no expert. They were about the same size also. The grove was growing in pretty much all-day complete shade. I'll be out there in a few days and maybe I'll get better pictures (and pictures of ripe fruit and seed if those in the photo are ripe and still on the plant).

jeffreyp · 03-10-2007, 06:55 AM

Gabe,

Why don't you think it's sikkimensis? I think the fruit and stalk looks alot like sikkimensis...

Gabe15 · 03-10-2007, 09:52 AM

There is clearly some wax on the petioles, M. sikkimensis does not have wax on mature plants. It could be a hybrid, it looks very similar to M. sikkimensis except for the wax in my opinion.

mrbungalow · 03-10-2007, 10:38 AM

I agree with Gabe. I am not getting "Thomsonii Vibes" here. The regular sikkimensis doesn't have that heavy wax-deposit. I also noticed the leaf-shapes looking like typical balbisiana, wich don't resemble sikkimensis at all. The fruit & flower looks identical to that I have seen of sikkimensis. But it looks very much like my musa helens. Could also be Musa sikkimensisX "Darjeeling giant" wich apparently is a hybrid between sikkimensis and balbisiana.

Erlend

Gabe15 · 03-10-2007, 10:46 AM

Ya after looking around a bit more, definetly not M. thomsonii.

bigdog · 03-10-2007, 06:58 PM

I really don't think that bloom looks like sikkimensis. Check out this link to a guy in GA, who has posted here once or twice, of his M. sikkimensis blooming. It tapers off rather abruptly, instead of the smooth taper of the plant I posted. Sikkimensis bloom also looks darker. I've never seen any wax on Musa sikkimensis either.

Gabe15 · 03-10-2007, 11:16 PM

Interestingly enough, there is wax on the plant posted in that link. When I saw the many giant stands of M. sikkimensis at the Huntington, none of them had wax at all.

bigdog · 03-10-2007, 11:53 PM

Ha! Good eye, Gabe! Funny I didn't even notice that, I was so focused on the flower. So perhaps M. sikkimensis is a variable species, as Simmonds wrote about a long time ago, and we could be looking at a few different forms in cultivation now.

Gabe15 · 03-11-2007, 12:44 AM

the flower in the link looks oddly purple to me. all the photos of sikkimensis i have seen show purpleish outsides but red insides, like many common edible bananas. also there are odd markings on the ends of the ovaries that i have not seen in sikkimensis.

bigdog · 03-11-2007, 10:01 PM

I dug this up from The Musaceae website regarding M. sikkimensis:

Quote:

Simmonds also noted specimens from Assam, Sikkim and Manipur, and possibly varietally distinct differences between them, and thought it possible that the species "ranges widely over the higher ground between Tibet and Burma".
Simmonds, 1956.

It is indeed a variable species, as Simmonds said, and these different areas that sikkimensis grows could have been isolated from each other for long enough to make this come about. The Himalayas are such an interesting area of the world!

Gabe15 · 03-11-2007, 11:29 PM

I would say if the seed looks like M. sikkimensis, then this plant is just that.

mrbungalow · 03-12-2007, 01:44 AM

If it quacks like a duck.... it must be sikkimensis.

Any chance of seeing a picture of the seeds?

Erlend

bigdog · 03-12-2007, 06:06 PM

Yes, seed pictures are coming soon! That should definitely help to settle it. I agree with M. sikkimensis now also...tentatively, LOL!

bigdog · 03-15-2007, 05:33 PM

OK, here are the seeds. Not the best quality picture, but my camera batteries were about to die. After seing these, I'm pretty sure that it is Musa sikkimensis. They are a bit smaller on average than M. sikkimensis seeds I've received in the past, but have the same, irregular, angular shape.

mrbungalow · 03-16-2007, 01:22 AM

The seeds show this plant is in the neighborhood of sikkimensis. But again, I think most likely it's Musa SikkimensisX or "Helen". Especially since the seeds are smaller. But could also be regular sikkimensis.

bigdog · 03-16-2007, 08:44 AM

Erlend, I don't think that it's 'Helen', as that is still an awfully new introduction, and this plant seems to be very well-established. These seeds are also black, whereas the 'Helen' seeds that I've received have been rather gray in color.
I did have a couple of dead M. sikkimensis seeds lying around, and used them as reference. They were noticeably larger, but the same, irregular shape. I think it could be a M. sikkimensis X also, or just M. sikkimensis. Whatever it is, I look forward to growing it in my yard!

03-08-2007, 05:35 PM	#1 (permalink)
bigdog ******* bigdog's Photo Gallery** Location: Gainesville, FL Find me on the map! Zone: 8b Name: Frank Join Date: Aug 2005 Posts: 2,002 BananaBucks : 733,167 Feedback: 7 / 100% Said "Thanks" 212 Times Was Thanked 1,787 Times in 502 Posts Said "Welcome to Bananas" 131 Times	Unknown Seeded Banana Presented for ID These are Rob's pictures of a seeded banana growing in Balboa Park, San Diego, CA. I've eliminated a bunch of seeded species, but I sure can't place it! Any ideas? The flower pic is kind of out of focus, and for that Rob apologizes! J/K Rob!

03-08-2007, 08:51 PM	#2 (permalink)
Gabe15 Moderator Gabe15's Photo Gallery Location: Oahu, Hawaii Find me on the map! Zone: 12 Name: Gabe Join Date: Jul 2005 Posts: 3,892 BananaBucks : 13,339,785 Feedback: 5 / 100% Said "Thanks" 1 Times Was Thanked 8,237 Times in 2,200 Posts Said "Welcome to Bananas" 8 Times	Re: Unknown Seeded Banana Presented for ID When I first saw these awhile back I thought maybe they were M. itinerans by the fruit, but that does not look right at all now. Then I thought maybe M. sikkimensis but that does not match either. The closet description Im thinking now is M. thomsonii. It would be nice to see a photo of the seeds if possible. __________________ Growing bananas in Colorado, Washington, Hawaii since 2004. Commercial banana farmer, 200+ varieties.

03-08-2007, 08:55 PM	#3 (permalink)
jeffreyp Zone 10, South Florida jeffreyp's Photo Gallery Location: Royal Palm Beach Find me on the map! Zone: 10 Join Date: Aug 2006 Posts: 870 BananaBucks : 140,266 Feedback: 1 / 100% Said "Thanks" 30 Times Was Thanked 590 Times in 298 Posts Said "Welcome to Bananas" 4 Times	Re: Unknown Seeded Banana Presented for ID It reminds me of Mysore, so maybe an indian variety is somewhere on the right track..

03-08-2007, 09:21 PM	#4 (permalink)
bigdog ******* bigdog's Photo Gallery** Location: Gainesville, FL Find me on the map! Zone: 8b Name: Frank Join Date: Aug 2005 Posts: 2,002 BananaBucks : 733,167 Feedback: 7 / 100% Said "Thanks" 212 Times Was Thanked 1,787 Times in 502 Posts Said "Welcome to Bananas" 131 Times	Re: Unknown Seeded Banana Presented for ID Some more info from Rob (hey Rob...weigh in here!). The pseudostems are about 28" in diameter. Leaf + petiole length is about 10'. Pseudostem height about 20'. The fruit is about 6" long, and apple/pear flavored. Hey Gabe, some characteristics of this plant do remind me of M. thomsonii, like the semi-pendulous infloresence, and the waxy bloom on the upper pseudostem. The fruits of this plant are much larger than M. thomsonii though, and the leaves look to be wider and rounded at the base, unlike M. thomsonii's narrower, lanceolate leaves. You know, it does resemble what has been sold as M. itinerans here at Agri-Starts and Banana-tree.com (but looks like M. yunnanensis). The fruit bunch doesn't look quite right though. I'm thinking it could be a hybrid. Gabe, can you direct Markku over here to have a look?

03-09-2007, 04:13 PM	#5 (permalink)
RobG7aChattTN Junior Member RobG7aChattTN's Photo Gallery Find me on the map! Join Date: Mar 2007 Posts: 422 BananaBucks : 19,096 Feedback: 1 / 100% Said "Thanks" 29 Times Was Thanked 438 Times in 234 Posts Said "Welcome to Bananas" 2 Times	Re: Unknown Seeded Banana Presented for ID That pretty much covers it. The seeds looked exactly like my M. sikkimensis that I got mail order last year, but I'm no expert. They were about the same size also. The grove was growing in pretty much all-day complete shade. I'll be out there in a few days and maybe I'll get better pictures (and pictures of ripe fruit and seed if those in the photo are ripe and still on the plant).

Members currently in the chatroom: 0
	The most chatters online in one day was 17, 09-06-2009. No one is currently using the chat.

03-10-2007, 06:55 AM	#6 (permalink)
jeffreyp Zone 10, South Florida jeffreyp's Photo Gallery Location: Royal Palm Beach Find me on the map! Zone: 10 Join Date: Aug 2006 Posts: 870 BananaBucks : 140,266 Feedback: 1 / 100% Said "Thanks" 30 Times Was Thanked 590 Times in 298 Posts Said "Welcome to Bananas" 4 Times	Re: Unknown Seeded Banana Presented for ID Gabe, Why don't you think it's sikkimensis? I think the fruit and stalk looks alot like sikkimensis...

03-10-2007, 09:52 AM	#7 (permalink)
Gabe15 Moderator Gabe15's Photo Gallery Location: Oahu, Hawaii Find me on the map! Zone: 12 Name: Gabe Join Date: Jul 2005 Posts: 3,892 BananaBucks : 13,339,785 Feedback: 5 / 100% Said "Thanks" 1 Times Was Thanked 8,237 Times in 2,200 Posts Said "Welcome to Bananas" 8 Times	Re: Unknown Seeded Banana Presented for ID There is clearly some wax on the petioles, M. sikkimensis does not have wax on mature plants. It could be a hybrid, it looks very similar to M. sikkimensis except for the wax in my opinion. __________________ Growing bananas in Colorado, Washington, Hawaii since 2004. Commercial banana farmer, 200+ varieties.

03-10-2007, 10:38 AM	#8 (permalink)
mrbungalow Freezing member mrbungalow's Photo Gallery Location: Bergen, Norway Find me on the map! Zone: 8 Name: Erlend Join Date: Feb 2006 Posts: 598 BananaBucks : 46,636 Feedback: 0 / 0% Said "Thanks" 14 Times Was Thanked 165 Times in 78 Posts Said "Welcome to Bananas" 3 Times	Re: Unknown Seeded Banana Presented for ID I agree with Gabe. I am not getting "Thomsonii Vibes" here. The regular sikkimensis doesn't have that heavy wax-deposit. I also noticed the leaf-shapes looking like typical balbisiana, wich don't resemble sikkimensis at all. The fruit & flower looks identical to that I have seen of sikkimensis. But it looks very much like my musa helens. Could also be Musa sikkimensisX "Darjeeling giant" wich apparently is a hybrid between sikkimensis and balbisiana. Erlend __________________

03-10-2007, 10:46 AM	#9 (permalink)
Gabe15 Moderator Gabe15's Photo Gallery Location: Oahu, Hawaii Find me on the map! Zone: 12 Name: Gabe Join Date: Jul 2005 Posts: 3,892 BananaBucks : 13,339,785 Feedback: 5 / 100% Said "Thanks" 1 Times Was Thanked 8,237 Times in 2,200 Posts Said "Welcome to Bananas" 8 Times	Re: Unknown Seeded Banana Presented for ID Ya after looking around a bit more, definetly not M. thomsonii. __________________ Growing bananas in Colorado, Washington, Hawaii since 2004. Commercial banana farmer, 200+ varieties.

03-10-2007, 06:58 PM	#10 (permalink)
bigdog ******* bigdog's Photo Gallery** Location: Gainesville, FL Find me on the map! Zone: 8b Name: Frank Join Date: Aug 2005 Posts: 2,002 BananaBucks : 733,167 Feedback: 7 / 100% Said "Thanks" 212 Times Was Thanked 1,787 Times in 502 Posts Said "Welcome to Bananas" 131 Times	Re: Unknown Seeded Banana Presented for ID I really don't think that bloom looks like sikkimensis. Check out this link to a guy in GA, who has posted here once or twice, of his M. sikkimensis blooming. It tapers off rather abruptly, instead of the smooth taper of the plant I posted. Sikkimensis bloom also looks darker. I've never seen any wax on Musa sikkimensis either.

03-10-2007, 11:16 PM	#11 (permalink)
Gabe15 Moderator Gabe15's Photo Gallery Location: Oahu, Hawaii Find me on the map! Zone: 12 Name: Gabe Join Date: Jul 2005 Posts: 3,892 BananaBucks : 13,339,785 Feedback: 5 / 100% Said "Thanks" 1 Times Was Thanked 8,237 Times in 2,200 Posts Said "Welcome to Bananas" 8 Times	Re: Unknown Seeded Banana Presented for ID Interestingly enough, there is wax on the plant posted in that link. When I saw the many giant stands of M. sikkimensis at the Huntington, none of them had wax at all. __________________ Growing bananas in Colorado, Washington, Hawaii since 2004. Commercial banana farmer, 200+ varieties.

03-10-2007, 11:53 PM	#12 (permalink)
bigdog ******* bigdog's Photo Gallery** Location: Gainesville, FL Find me on the map! Zone: 8b Name: Frank Join Date: Aug 2005 Posts: 2,002 BananaBucks : 733,167 Feedback: 7 / 100% Said "Thanks" 212 Times Was Thanked 1,787 Times in 502 Posts Said "Welcome to Bananas" 131 Times	Re: Unknown Seeded Banana Presented for ID Ha! Good eye, Gabe! Funny I didn't even notice that, I was so focused on the flower. So perhaps M. sikkimensis is a variable species, as Simmonds wrote about a long time ago, and we could be looking at a few different forms in cultivation now.

03-11-2007, 12:44 AM	#13 (permalink)
Gabe15 Moderator Gabe15's Photo Gallery Location: Oahu, Hawaii Find me on the map! Zone: 12 Name: Gabe Join Date: Jul 2005 Posts: 3,892 BananaBucks : 13,339,785 Feedback: 5 / 100% Said "Thanks" 1 Times Was Thanked 8,237 Times in 2,200 Posts Said "Welcome to Bananas" 8 Times	Re: Unknown Seeded Banana Presented for ID the flower in the link looks oddly purple to me. all the photos of sikkimensis i have seen show purpleish outsides but red insides, like many common edible bananas. also there are odd markings on the ends of the ovaries that i have not seen in sikkimensis. __________________ Growing bananas in Colorado, Washington, Hawaii since 2004. Commercial banana farmer, 200+ varieties.

03-11-2007, 11:29 PM	#15 (permalink)
Gabe15 Moderator Gabe15's Photo Gallery Location: Oahu, Hawaii Find me on the map! Zone: 12 Name: Gabe Join Date: Jul 2005 Posts: 3,892 BananaBucks : 13,339,785 Feedback: 5 / 100% Said "Thanks" 1 Times Was Thanked 8,237 Times in 2,200 Posts Said "Welcome to Bananas" 8 Times	Re: Unknown Seeded Banana Presented for ID I would say if the seed looks like M. sikkimensis, then this plant is just that. __________________ Growing bananas in Colorado, Washington, Hawaii since 2004. Commercial banana farmer, 200+ varieties.

03-12-2007, 01:44 AM	#16 (permalink)
mrbungalow Freezing member mrbungalow's Photo Gallery Location: Bergen, Norway Find me on the map! Zone: 8 Name: Erlend Join Date: Feb 2006 Posts: 598 BananaBucks : 46,636 Feedback: 0 / 0% Said "Thanks" 14 Times Was Thanked 165 Times in 78 Posts Said "Welcome to Bananas" 3 Times	Re: Unknown Seeded Banana Presented for ID If it quacks like a duck.... it must be sikkimensis. Any chance of seeing a picture of the seeds? Erlend __________________

03-12-2007, 06:06 PM	#17 (permalink)
bigdog ******* bigdog's Photo Gallery** Location: Gainesville, FL Find me on the map! Zone: 8b Name: Frank Join Date: Aug 2005 Posts: 2,002 BananaBucks : 733,167 Feedback: 7 / 100% Said "Thanks" 212 Times Was Thanked 1,787 Times in 502 Posts Said "Welcome to Bananas" 131 Times	Re: Unknown Seeded Banana Presented for ID Yes, seed pictures are coming soon! That should definitely help to settle it. I agree with M. sikkimensis now also...tentatively, LOL!

03-15-2007, 05:33 PM	#18 (permalink)
bigdog ******* bigdog's Photo Gallery** Location: Gainesville, FL Find me on the map! Zone: 8b Name: Frank Join Date: Aug 2005 Posts: 2,002 BananaBucks : 733,167 Feedback: 7 / 100% Said "Thanks" 212 Times Was Thanked 1,787 Times in 502 Posts Said "Welcome to Bananas" 131 Times	Re: Unknown Seeded Banana Presented for ID OK, here are the seeds. Not the best quality picture, but my camera batteries were about to die. After seing these, I'm pretty sure that it is Musa sikkimensis. They are a bit smaller on average than M. sikkimensis seeds I've received in the past, but have the same, irregular, angular shape.

03-16-2007, 01:22 AM	#19 (permalink)
mrbungalow Freezing member mrbungalow's Photo Gallery Location: Bergen, Norway Find me on the map! Zone: 8 Name: Erlend Join Date: Feb 2006 Posts: 598 BananaBucks : 46,636 Feedback: 0 / 0% Said "Thanks" 14 Times Was Thanked 165 Times in 78 Posts Said "Welcome to Bananas" 3 Times	Re: Unknown Seeded Banana Presented for ID The seeds show this plant is in the neighborhood of sikkimensis. But again, I think most likely it's Musa SikkimensisX or "Helen". Especially since the seeds are smaller. But could also be regular sikkimensis. __________________

03-16-2007, 08:44 AM	#20 (permalink)
bigdog ******* bigdog's Photo Gallery** Location: Gainesville, FL Find me on the map! Zone: 8b Name: Frank Join Date: Aug 2005 Posts: 2,002 BananaBucks : 733,167 Feedback: 7 / 100% Said "Thanks" 212 Times Was Thanked 1,787 Times in 502 Posts Said "Welcome to Bananas" 131 Times	Re: Unknown Seeded Banana Presented for ID Erlend, I don't think that it's 'Helen', as that is still an awfully new introduction, and this plant seems to be very well-established. These seeds are also black, whereas the 'Helen' seeds that I've received have been rather gray in color. I did have a couple of dead M. sikkimensis seeds lying around, and used them as reference. They were noticeably larger, but the same, irregular shape. I think it could be a M. sikkimensis X also, or just M. sikkimensis. Whatever it is, I look forward to growing it in my yard!

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Unknown Ensete	Valenciaguy	Banana Identification	2	12-14-2006 05:16 PM
Unknown Infestation Problem Need HELP	GAPEye	Other Plants	2	12-04-2006 05:04 PM
Unknown Ft. Meyer bananas?	PaulOdin	Main Banana Discussion	10	08-20-2006 06:16 PM
Chromosomes count and seeded bananas	Tropicallvr	Main Banana Discussion	5	08-20-2006 08:30 AM
Unknown nanner?	tlturbo	Banana Identification	6	08-10-2006 05:38 PM