Bananas.org

Bananas.org (http://www.bananas.org/)
-   Species Bananas (http://www.bananas.org/f16/)
-   -   "Burmese Blue"- has the species been determinied yet? (http://www.bananas.org/f16/burmese-blue-has-species-been-determinied-6362.html)

Eric-Orlando,FL 10-28-2008 12:19 PM

"Burmese Blue"- has the species been determinied yet?
 
Has it been determined what "Burmese Blue" is yet? a variety of Musa itinerans?

Gabe15 10-28-2008 01:04 PM

Re: "Burmese Blue"- has the species been determinied yet?
 
Yes, its definitely a variety of M. itinerans, but it may not be a published form (according to what I have heard). It seems to be rather similar to var. guangdongensis, but may prove to be distinct.

bigdog 10-30-2008 11:32 AM

Re: "Burmese Blue"- has the species been determinied yet?
 
It is definitely a Musa itinerans variety, but as Gabe said, has not been described yet. It is a huge banana, around 35 feet of pseudostem, close to the size of var. xishuangbannensis, so it isn't very similar to var. guangdongensis. Whatever has been on the market as 'Burmese Blue' in all likelihood is not it.

I spoke with Dr. Hugo Volkaert at Kasetsart U. while in Thailand, and asked him about 'Burmese Blue'. He offered to take me to see plants! Ugh...too bad I couldn't take him up on that, as I was with a UT-sponsored program with not much free time. Anyway, he said that he could show me 20 different varieties of Musa itinerans in Thailand alone. Next time I travel there, I will take him up on that!!

Worm_Farmer 11-01-2008 02:36 PM

Re: "Burmese Blue"- has the species been determinied yet?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bigdog (Post 56121)
It is definitely a Musa itinerans variety, but as Gabe said, has not been described yet. It is a huge banana, around 35 feet of pseudostem, close to the size of var. xishuangbannensis, so it isn't very similar to var. guangdongensis. Whatever has been on the market as 'Burmese Blue' in all likelihood is not it.

I spoke with Dr. Hugo Volkaert at Kasetsart U. while in Thailand, and asked him about 'Burmese Blue'. He offered to take me to see plants! Ugh...too bad I couldn't take him up on that, as I was with a UT-sponsored program with not much free time. Anyway, he said that he could show me 20 different varieties of Musa itinerans in Thailand alone. Next time I travel there, I will take him up on that!!

35' Tall?? Holey smokes! How long does it take to flower? Is it just a cooking banana like Saba?

Gabe15 11-01-2008 09:30 PM

Re: "Burmese Blue"- has the species been determinied yet?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bigdog (Post 56121)
It is definitely a Musa itinerans variety, but as Gabe said, has not been described yet. It is a huge banana, around 35 feet of pseudostem, close to the size of var. xishuangbannensis, so it isn't very similar to var. guangdongensis. Whatever has been on the market as 'Burmese Blue' in all likelihood is not it.

There are multiple varieties of M. itinerans with the purple fruits. The ones I have seen flowering as 'Burmese Blue' in the US (at Harry P. Leu in Orlando and the Hawaii Tropical Botanic Garden on the Hamakua Coast, Big Island) both were only about 10-12ft. Over the summer, we planted some in the conservatory of the Denver Botanic Gardens, so I will be able to watch those grow over time when I return to Colorado periodically. However, Don Chafin informs me that he pollinated his 'Burmese Blue' and did not get purple fruits, so if we are to consider that all of the 'Burmese Blue' on the market are the same clone, it is possible they are not the intended M. itinerans variety at all. I don't think environmental factors would change their natural heights or (mature) fruit color so drastically. Obviously, the whole story of this plant is not known yet.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Worm_Farmer (Post 56270)
35' Tall?? Holey smokes! How long does it take to flower? Is it just a cooking banana like Saba?

It is a seeded wild banana, so not like 'Saba' at all which is a cultivated edible banana variety.

Eric-Orlando,FL 11-04-2008 08:35 AM

Re: "Burmese Blue"- has the species been determinied yet?
 
Both of the clumps we have came from Going Bananas. They have never really thrived here. We have had several flower but only one set fruit but it never full set. Ours only got to about 10ft.





bigdog 11-04-2008 07:29 PM

Re: "Burmese Blue"- has the species been determinied yet?
 
That definitely is a Musa itinerans variety, but not 'Burmese Blue' as far as I can tell, and I'm just going on what I've read and heard from experts in the field. 'Burmese Blue' should get about 30-35 feet of pseudostem.

I have a couple of pics of the real deal, fruit pics that is. Wish I could post them, but they are not mine to post. The fruit is incredibly purple! Not a dull purple either, almost a shiny purple color. Very vivid and beautiful. I have a Musa itinerans variety, collected from Thailand, that gets to over 30 feet of pseudostem, but not sure if it's 'Burmese Blue' or not. I'll probably never know if I grow it in Knoxville, LOL.

Gabe15 11-04-2008 07:55 PM

Re: "Burmese Blue"- has the species been determinied yet?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bigdog (Post 56462)
That definitely is a Musa itinerans variety, but not 'Burmese Blue' as far as I can tell, and I'm just going on what I've read and heard from experts in the field. 'Burmese Blue' should get about 30-35 feet of pseudostem.

I have a couple of pics of the real deal, fruit pics that is. Wish I could post them, but they are not mine to post. The fruit is incredibly purple! Not a dull purple either, almost a shiny purple color. Very vivid and beautiful. I have a Musa itinerans variety, collected from Thailand, that gets to over 30 feet of pseudostem, but not sure if it's 'Burmese Blue' or not. I'll probably never know if I grow it in Knoxville, LOL.

We should note that regardless of whether or not this variety of M. itinerans has purple fruit, it seems as though this is what is still called 'Burmese Blue' in the horticultural market.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:41 PM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.6.8, Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Limited.
All content © Bananas.org & the respective author.