Log in

View Full Version : Bananas for zone 6


BananaLee
10-08-2009, 02:34 PM
Hey guys! here is a list of bananas that have been reported to survive zone 6.

List
Musa Basjoo (zone 5)
Musa Basjoo 'Sakhalin' (zone 5)
Musa Sikkimensis (zone 5)
Musa Sikkimensis "Daj Giant" (zone 5)
Musa Sikkimensis "red tiger" (zone 5)
Musa Itinerans (zone 5 or 6)
Musa Itinerans 'Gigantea' (zone 5 or 6)
Musa Yunnanensis (zone 5 or 6)
Musa tibet (zone 5 or 6)
Musa Bordelon (zone 6)
Musa velutina (zone 6)
Musa balbisiana (zone 6)
Musa Black Balbisiana (zone 6)
Musella lasiocarpa (zone 5)

I know Musella isn't a real banana but it's related. If you have any questions, I'll try to answer them to the best of my ability. Thanx! God Bless! BananaLee:woohoonaner::doggyandnaner:

natej740
10-08-2009, 04:50 PM
Thanks....Can you protect them like a basjoo and theyll come back in the spring, or do you mean dig them up and put them in a crawl space???

BananaLee
10-08-2009, 04:55 PM
Just protection! some more than others!

PAbananas
10-08-2009, 07:28 PM
Im getting ready to put mine down for the winter. Ive seen different ways of doing this but what do you think is the time to do this? Oct, Nov or dec. I am in PA they say zone 7. I think its a bit colder like 5-6 Dont want to wait to long or kill the plant. Thanks Dan

BananaLee
10-08-2009, 07:56 PM
Im getting ready to put mine down for the winter. Ive seen different ways of doing this but what do you think is the time to do this? Oct, Nov or dec. I am in PA they say zone 7. I think its a bit colder like 5-6 Dont want to wait to long or kill the plant. Thanks Dan

If you overwinter them outdoors you can try to save the Pseudostem by covering it with straw, pine needles (anything that will keep them dry) and them cover that with burlap and/or other stuff to cover it, before the first killing frost. Or you can wait after the killing frost and cut off the mushy part of pseudostem and mulch it heavily. Hope this helps! God Bless! BananaLee

Randy4ut
10-08-2009, 08:31 PM
Are you sure you are not is zone 8 or 9? Also, where did you get your hardiness info? Sure would love to know what a musella is if it isn't a banana. I thought there were three genus of banana and they were, musa, musella, and ensete.... Think you need to double check your hardiness info. I am not arguing but I don't want some new banana grower, or palm grower for that matter to expect the same results as you have stated that you are having and then be disappointed when they are not as hardy as they thought!!!

sunfish
10-08-2009, 08:55 PM
http://www.bananas.org/f2/musa-musella-ensete-im-confused-1055.html#post6817

blownz281
10-09-2009, 08:09 AM
Musa Basjoo I know from first hand is hardy with out even mulching. I grew them for five years in Ohio with no protection what so ever,I would just cut them down. I even have one growing in a pot that is clay soil HAHA.

Its pushing it but All the others might be fine if they are out of the wind and up against a house. Also if they are wrapped up and kept dry. Its always a good idea to save a pup from each plant you try cause one winter will be different then the next. Plus members need to remember size of the plant and age will factor in too. A young small plant will not enjoy cold snaps for long periods or soil being to wet. Plus you can't really trust 100% what you read online from vendors,its more trial and error then anything else. I have had people tell me when I first started out working on my camaro years ago,that I need this part and that for my Supercharged engine to run right. Well come to find out some parts I didn't need and was able to resell them.

jimmmy
10-09-2009, 08:52 AM
hey don't forget orinoco the tall zone 6 that makes the very best cooking banana! jimmmy

Randy4ut
10-09-2009, 09:17 AM
Musa Basjoo I know from first hand is hardy with out even mulching. I grew them for five years in Ohio with no protection what so ever,I would just cut them down. I even have one growing in a pot that is clay soil HAHA.

Its pushing it but All the others might be fine if they are out of the wind and up against a house. Also if they are wrapped up and kept dry. Its always a good idea to save a pup from each plant you try cause one winter will be different then the next. Plus members need to remember size of the plant and age will factor in too. A young small plant will not enjoy cold snaps for long periods or soil being to wet. Plus you can't really trust 100% what you read online from vendors,its more trial and error then anything else. I have had people tell me when I first started out working on my camaro years ago,that I need this part and that for my Supercharged engine to run right. Well come to find out some parts I didn't need and was able to resell them.

What you are saying may be true, but if you have to wrap and/or protect, then it is NOT hardy for that area. True hardiness is uncertain due to many variables, but to say a certain banana is hardy in a cetain area, then protecting is really creating a different and thus cannot be a truly hardiness evaluation for that particular area. You have indeed made some valid points and appreciate the input...

Randy4ut
10-09-2009, 09:20 AM
hey don't forget orinoco the tall zone 6 that makes the very best cooking banana! jimmmy


Even though orinoco will overwinter in my 7a/b with only mulch, I know of no one in my area that have them that are able to get bananas to produce. Only one I know of that has successfully had an orinoco to fruit is BigDog, and he overwintered his pstem under his house and had a nice pstem to start with in the spring. I wish there was a variety of banana that would overwinter outside here in zone 7, much less in colder areas, and still produce fruit!!! Still no luck from anyone I know of!!!!

blownz281
10-09-2009, 09:49 AM
Thanks Randy, my way of thinking is if I have to dig it up or protect it,then its not worth my time. Putting mulch over something is as far as I will go. Don't have the time or money to waste.

BananaLee
10-09-2009, 06:02 PM
Thank you! That's what I mean! What I mean is you can grow these with protection in your yard in zone 6. But if these are really zone 7-8 plants and I can grow them here by covering them, does that mean I can grow Orinoco and just cover it or no? I experiment with things so if something dies in the winter I just drop it or if I really like it, I will plant it again in a more protected area.

mbfirey
10-09-2009, 08:05 PM
Plants delights Nursery located in central NC zone 7b says this about the orinoco:
PDN -- Musa 'Orinoco' (http://www.plantdelights.com/Catalog/Current/Detail/04797.html)
"This amazing banana is one of the most cold hardy of the edible fruiting bananas, commonly grown for fruit in the US Gulf Coast region. Musa 'Orinoco' amazes visitors with its nice fruit clusters in our Zone 7 garden. For us, a height of 10' is common, although M. 'Orinoco' can reach 21' in more hospitable climates. In the colder climates, cut the banana fruit stalk before the first frost, and keep it indoors in a bucket of water until the fruit ripens. In Zone 7, I recommend surrounding the trunks with a 3'-4' tall cage filled with leaves to preserve next year's fruiting stalks. Pot size: 2 qt. (1.892 L) "


They claim to be able to get fruit- I picked up some elsewhere (their prices are little high) and am going to give them a try next year in the zone 7/8 border.

Randy4ut
10-09-2009, 08:10 PM
Tony at PDN is pretty generous with the zone ratings of most of his plants. I wish you luck and hope you are successful with it, but don't be diappointed if you do not get it to bear fruit if you have a true 7b winter. Important thing is to save as much pstem as possible and cross your fingers!!!!

mbfirey
10-09-2009, 08:44 PM
I'm a bit further south....in SC barely in zone 8 so I'm hoping. Yeah it seems that their zones ratings are generous.
I'll see what happens.

BananaLee
10-10-2009, 09:53 AM
Thank you for the info! God Bless! BananaLee

BananaLee
10-11-2009, 02:51 PM
It's odd how Tony says he "conservative" with his zone ratings! Lol!

Ueberwinden
10-11-2009, 03:39 PM
I have a couple of comments just from my experiences with plants.

First, The USDA hardiness zones are only guide lines. You must keep this in mind when you are purchasing plants. Decide how much effort you are willing to put into maintaining this plant. Not much effort, purchase below your zone. Remember this plant will hopefully be a long term investment requiring YEARS of care. Next I must confess that Tony's zone ratings are not always accurate. Most of this is because he rates them according to what his experience is. Brian at Brians Botanicals has Trachycarpus fortunei that has survived subzero temps in a zone 6, Tony rates them as "Zone 7-9, At least"
Some of the bananas that were mentioned in this thread I was surprised that claims were made as hardy in a zone 6. I guess it would be better if the claim was stated as " can survive in a zone 6 with protection", since bananas are not native to American cold climates. I have plants that I grow in the ground here in a zone 6 that normaly are not grown here, but this is my niche in my nursery. Other nurseries here do not grow the plants I grow because of the time and care required to maintain them here. They can grow here but require special care to survive the winter.

Michael

mbfirey
10-11-2009, 04:11 PM
I totally agree zones are a very broad/vague kind of thing....I really don't trust every trust the zone rating from one site- if I'm shopping for a certain plant, I look at lots of vendor's zone ratings- take the high and the low and split the difference.
I've seen Alocasia Calidora rated for zone 9+ but there is a seller on ebay that has it in 7b. Variegated Tapioca, same thing, most say 9+ but a seller on ebay has it at zone 8. And before anyone trashes on ebay sellers- these are 2 sellers that several folks on this site has spoken positively about.
I mainly posted the quote about the orinoco because it said that PDN gotten them to fruit in their zone, which shows that it's possible (unless they made it up). I'm sure that it depends on how you grow them.

BananaLee
10-11-2009, 06:18 PM
I have a couple of comments just from my experiences with plants.

First, The USDA hardiness zones are only guide lines. You must keep this in mind when you are purchasing plants. Decide how much effort you are willing to put into maintaining this plant. Not much effort, purchase below your zone. Remember this plant will hopefully be a long term investment requiring YEARS of care. Next I must confess that Tony's zone ratings are not always accurate. Most of this is because he rates them according to what his experience is. Brian at Brians Botanicals has Trachycarpus fortunei that has survived subzero temps in a zone 6, Tony rates them as "Zone 7-9, At least"
Some of the bananas that were mentioned in this thread I was surprised that claims were made as hardy in a zone 6. I guess it would be better if the claim was stated as " can survive in a zone 6 with protection", since bananas are not native to American cold climates. I have plants that I grow in the ground here in a zone 6 that normaly are not grown here, but this is my niche in my nursery. Other nurseries here do not grow the plants I grow because of the time and care required to maintain them here. They can grow here but require special care to survive the winter.

Michael

Thanx a bunch Michael! That's what I think the reports mean they "can survive zone 6 with protection". That's what this was about. They Michael, what plants do you grow that are not labeled zone 6?

Ueberwinden
10-12-2009, 07:53 AM
BL,
I grow Plumeria, Bougainvillea, Brugmansia, bananas, and bamboo on a regular basis. I am getting away from Brugmansia, so if you know anyone who is interested in cuttings or the whole plant let me know. I also grow different cactus and succulents, what I grow varies. I also grow different tropicals usually from seed. I have a bunch of alocasia, calocasia, some pinecone ginger. I germinated several types of canna this summer. I was in Sanibel/Captiva Island this Spring and was able to buy a bunch of plants that are native to southwest Florida. I find them quite interesting. I bought a strangler fig, a Gumbo Limbo, some Sea Oats, a Sea Grape, and several others. Here lately I have had an interested in tropical fruit other than my passion for bananas. I have a dragon fruit that I hope will produce next season, and a passion fruit tree that was started from seed and an Orange tree my daughter bought for me several years ago. I will be growing a selection of succulent trees from Africa this winter, and tropical trees from South America also. I also want to start some Atropa Belladonna this winter, I found a good seed source that I want to try. I have Lotus seed I want to get started and in early spring, caster beans, more canna, crape myrtle, and some Moso bamboo. Looks like a busy winter/Spring, we will see what I actually get done.

Michael

BananaLee
10-12-2009, 12:27 PM
Thanx Ueberwinden! Are those listed overwintered outside or not? If so, which are overwintered outside? I neeed to know! Thanx!

Ueberwinden
10-12-2009, 01:36 PM
BL,

None of my plants are over wintered outside because either they wouldn't make it in this climate or they would take too long to recover to make it profitable for sales. I made divisions of my Phy. Nigra (Black Bamboo), and I have a Phy Henon, and a Fargesia (Dragonshead Bamboo) which are outside for the winter. This will be their first taste of winter and peditors (deer, rabbits). It usually takes about 10 years to develope a mature grove. Everything else will spend the winter in my growroom.

Michael

BananaLee
10-12-2009, 02:42 PM
Thanx for the info!